I have an American Boxer of my own currently so I totally understand and love their goofy personalities. When I said goofy I think I was just meaning that facial shapes (something about the eyes??) seem different than my American ... keeping in mind she is byb. I didn’t mean to be rude towards anyone!
I have looked at GSDs, as well as other breeds but I always come back to the Boxer.
I’ll look into all of that, thank you for your opinion!
Rude??? LOL, naw man nothing to apologize for?? American Line Boxer aka The Clown Prince or Princes of the Dog World! They were not an accident, they were the goal! Almost the "Perfect Family" pet but "Patience Required," as they can be a time consuming PIA to train, for a lot of folks???
But typically they are not a potential Law Suit on four paw's looking for a place to happen?? AKA Working line GSD.
I could recommend a Boxer to some folk's I know. I would never recommend a WL GSD, to anyone I know. The Euro Boxer's however are "still," the real deal Working Dog ... they are still doing the K9 gig in America, in the Mid West at any rate. You won't see them on Patrol here WL GSD and Mal's only.
I'm suspicious of the Euro's myself?? As I tend to put it, I'm not looking for a Wl GSD in a Boxer suit?? The Euro do seem to still have the "Aloof," with stranger's bit till they know you, then your good with them and they can "apparently be goofy!" My baby girl Struddell ... did not know what a stranger was??
But the eyes thing?? Yeah I get that ... very expressive but they can turn that off and on in a Blink (no pun interned.) I have seen no American Line Flashy female that had owner's that were struggling with her. My GSD was safely outside her front yard gate. We were talking and met there other dog. And they said we have a Boxer also. But she does not like other dog's.
We were on the other side of the gate so I sure I'd luv to see her. Well they brought her out, straining at the leash. And she stared at my 113 GSD like he was raw meat! And she did not make a sound! I was kinda stunned?? I said thank you she's beautiful (and she was) and me and Rocky got the He$$ out of there. She was definitely "not," a typical Goofy American Line Boxer! her eyes "said," I'll tear your dog a new one if given the chance?? I believed her she was a scary looking Boxer!
But the eyes, Ok here you go "Cliff vom Grand Kevin,"
And here he is at work.
Now that dog still has the same "eye's," and you know a "goofy look??" But you'd not wanna screw with him.
My GSD on the other hand ... had a limited range of expression?? His ear's alway's pointed forward. Off leash on a midnight walk one time ... he was talking point. We traded the position back and forth. When he got tired of leading ... he would step to the side let me lead and he would follow. No words were needed ... it's just what we did. But one night on one of our midnight's I heard Coyotes in the distance??
We go out on our typical route and not far from home. He stops ... he look's left listen's and right and listen's?? Then turn's around walks past me and head's for home??? I watch him walk again ... WTH?? I stand and peer into the distance and listen, you know as if I could hear something he apparently heard?? I said screw this ... I trust my dog! And I followed him home.
Had I been walking my Baby Girl Struddell?? Well it would have been different?? I was a serious hard core Helicopter Dad! I found her well you know ... "hard to read??" You'd really have no idea what she was "thinking about anything??" I did the thinking and she would follow. So with her ... if there was an ambush ahead we'd have walked right into it! Cuz you know "Dad," must know what he's doing???
I really Luv'd my "Baby Girl," but honestly I could never tell what she was thinking about ... anything?? the thick layer of "Goofy," was a filter?? And you really had no idea what was in her head??
By contrast ... I overrode my GSD once! Loose Dog encounter, one of 17 or so?? But always no contact with my dog, cuz you know ... get by me dog if you can! But hey unlike my dog ... I can't see in the dark???
Rocky got nipped he was fine but I was pretty pissed off! And the dog got the hell out of Dodge once I understood where she was! Rocky saw her but he was obeying me! Stand down ... I got this! It was how we rolled but I can't see at night??? Aww well it was fine ultimately and my wife found out when she went to tell the property owner's what happened.
That the dog that got us was an EX MWD DDD, that went on task and got us by escaping threw the fence while her mates distracted me! And one of the 4 other dog's was an Irish Wolfhound cross! And you can bet that was the one I was watching!! I lost situational awareness as it were??
I never saw the GSD closing in?? But Rocky did, he turned to face her! And then she changed direction and brushed by my thigh to get to him cuz she knew I did not see her?? At that point she struck Rocky and he yelped and now I knew where she was and she said, hey good enough ... I'm out of here! I was ticked off! The one time I did not listen to my GSD and this happens!
So even though I don't recommend Wl GSD ... I get them! A Euro Boxer maybe closer to a Wl GSD in instinct without all the people issue's?? Cuz my particular GSD ... did not trust "people!" He was my buddy but he was a serious responsibility!
A Euro Boxer maybe a better compromise?? I don't know?? As I have never owned and really never met one?? In Ca all you saw were AL Boxer's and in NV it seem's to be AL and AL/Euro's?? The Al/Euro's seem to be very "Boxer like??" Aloof at first but when they know just as "Goofy," as one expect a Boxer to be!
With most people in the home ... my GSD was more like "Glad to see you ... when you leaving??" Unlike my Struddell who's favorite time of year was Halloween and the Holiday's there after cuz everybody was coming to see me!! And for the most part our Male guest were!
Female guest were kinda cool to her?? She would wait politely for there attention?? After a few minuet's, it was well screw you I'll go play with the guy's!!
Sigh she was off the hook! Giggles and laugh's ensued. And if I tried to get her to dial it down ... then suddenly I'm the bad guy???
And yet ... out and about I could turn off or on an "Open Desert Bunny Chase," with the word "No!" It depended on which way the bunny broke towards the Highway or Towards the Mountains??
Oh well they were "both," great dog's. I miss them dearly. And for me ... I put just as much value on Dedication and loyalty to family (my GSD) as I do Goofy and Laughter?? Time will tell for me??
But in the "Boxer's," I have met and worked with ... the Euro/American's seem to be a compromise?? I'd be crushed if I had a Boxer ... that was not "Goofy??" But hey that's just me ... or is it?? Good Luck with your hunt and Welcome Aboard ... if I did not say that already!