When Abby goes in the house make sure you say bad girl and put her nose near it some ppl put there nose in it, but I cant do that. Jessie is 4 months and she doesnt go in the house anymore. Recently we hung her collar up were she can get it and were we can see it, and when its time to go outside we say Jessie let go bathroom get ur collar and she hits it. The first night we taught her she was great. A few hrs went by and she hits it. We took her out and she did both. Jessie hasnt done any accidents I think in like 2 weeks. It really takes time. To be though I think 9 months is a long time. You should take her out every two hrs. Thats a little weird how she can learn everything else just not pee.