Abby is now 9 months. We have had her since 5.5 months. Still not housebroken. She goes outside and is typically good (when we are watching her with an eagle eye) and is great in her crate...but turn your head for 2 seconds when she's out of her crate and she's sure to go. Is 9 months and not housebroken crazy? She still doesn't give us a signal to go out but we just take her very frequently and watch for any pacing that she does. We were taking advantage of her sensitivity to discipline for a week or 2 but then we had a couple poop-eating incidents as a result (she was trying to hide it i think) so we have had to stop that. She learns everything else so perfectly, people are amazed! (Just for fun recently i taught her to "turn". it took 10 minutes. now I say turn and she does this little ballerina manuver, so cute!) But I just want her to stop going in the house!!!! 10 minutes to stay, 10 mintues to turn, 2 minutes to sit, etc. 4.5 months and still can't understand not to pee in the house?