Nope ALS is fine for any time IMO food labeled as "puppy, adult, senior" is pure marketing. I again IMO think you should choose a food by whats in the bad, not on the label. Look at the ingredients first.
I would try a food switch. Also if he is not gaining much weight then also supplement him with some cottage cheese, an extra meal, etc. Most of the holistic stuff is All Life Stages. Just pay attention to fat and protein count
Canidae does have a lot of filler, Oggie had similiar issues with it. Unfortunately the richer kibbles seem to just make it worse. Depends on the dog of course but just keep trying high-grade kibbles. I agree that "puppy food" is a gimmick, just find a qualtiy all life stages kibble.
As for the weight.....is he growing (up and long....not just out), does he look healthy, does he seem energized and playful? I don't think 48 pounds at 7 months is a concern. Personally I believe slow, gradual growth is ideal for the longterm. Too many people are in a rush to fill out their pup and I think it's a dangerous road to head down.
He is growing, but he is very thin. I posted in the health concern sections that he is pooping over 5 or 6 times a day at times. There has been times that he will poop 3 or 4 times before noon and he hasn't eaten anything yet. Thats my concern and he hasn't been gaining much weight so I thought the reason was the food.
Well I agree to switch the food. Short of a medical issue, it probably just means he's not digesting a lot of the filler (rice, etc). If he's growing though, I would be certain he's absorbing protein and important nutrients. Maybe he's more sensitive to grains than other dogs, maybe try a grainless food. I switched to raw because all the kibbles seemed to go right through Oggie. Now he barely has to go, which means he's absorbing most of what I give him, but he's not necessarily growing at a faster rate. He's actually quite scrawny at the moment but he eats like a pig. Some say actually that a better digestible diet will promote slower growth. So I wouldn't worry about weight, just try to find a food that seems to agreee with him.
Often when puppies get to around 6-9 months they slow down in their growth and weight gain. I know Lola shot up to about 48 lbs at probably 6-8 months of age and she is 52 now at 17 months old. She isn't going to be a huge dog and it's not nutritionally related. I never had pooping problems with Lola on canidae and my neighbor feeds her 2 canidae with no problems. Canidae is a very good dog food without a lot of fillers.
I think your dog is fine for age & weight. Many boxers keep filling out until they are two years old. If your dog keeps gaining 3 lbs a month until it's 1 year old, it'll be 63lbs at one year old. That is not small.
Just to clarify, I think Canidae is a great food and that is why I wanted to feed it to Kiah, many of the boxers here do very well on it. It just wasn't a good choice for Kiah and the allergies she has.
Chicken Meal, Turkey Meal, Brown Rice, White Rice, Lamb Meal,
First 5 ingredients in Canidae, not bad at all but does have two grains (filers) but they are not poor quality. However for those who feed raw or go by the dogs has no need for Carbs in their diet, yes it does have IMO too many grains being 3rd and 4th in the list. But a great food for dogs not accustomed to a grainless diet
Canidae has those first 5 ingredients and then it has chicken fat and herring meal, so it has 2 grains in the first 7 ingredients.
Half of timberwolf organics dog foods have 2 carbs in the first 5 and the other half have 2 in the first 6, and their generally considered one of the best premium foods. Reason is, without the carbs it gets really hard to make a kibble hold its shape (too much meat and the kibble falls apart when it's dried).
Reality is, IMO, if the dog can't handle canidae, more than likely they'd do better with more carbs. Put them on Iams or Pro Plan and I bet their stools firm right up.
Yesterday we picked up Solid Gold Hund-n-Flocken. Bruce LOVED it. I have never seen him react to food like this. We mixed his Canidae with it and he was almost trying to just eat the Soild Gold but he ate it all. This morning, no eye boogers.
Its been almost a week of feeding him Hund-n-Flocken and he loves it. Its amazing now that he eats in the morning, he never did before. And he eats the whole bowl at one sitting. I'm an idiot because I went to the pet store and bought "Hundchen Flocken" instead of "Hund-n-Flocken", but he wolfed it down when I fed it to him regardless. Hundchen Flocken contains:
Protein, Min 28%
Fat, Min 14%
Fiber, Max 4%
Moisture, Max 10%
Calories per cup, 410
Protein, Min 22%
Fat, Min 10%
Fiber, Max 4%
Moisture, Max 10%
Calories per cup, 367
The owner of the Pet Store said at Bruce's age, (7 months) I could feed him this for another month or so.