I agree.I feel like there is a new thread exactly like this every time I turn around. All pups are different, comparing doesn't really do you any good. Now if you put up a picture and asked if your pup looked under weight then we could actually give an opinion. And not all vets understand want a lean dog is, they personally would like to have a heftier dog so they tell you they need to gain weight. Boxers are not hefty dogs.